El rol de abogados y jueces en el surgimiento del control judicial de constitucionalidad en los Estados Unidos

  • Manuel José García-Mansilla Facultad de Derecho, Universidad Austral
Palabras clave: control judicial de constitucionalidad, constitución, Marbury v. Madison, jueces, función judicial, deber judicial, separación de poderes

Resumen

Este trabajo propone la necesidad de revisar el rol que cumplieron abogados y jueces en el surgimiento del control judicial de constitucionalidad en los Estados Unidos durante la década de 1780, varios años antes que el Chief Justice John Marshall redactara su célebre decisión en el fallo Marbury v. Madison.

Descargas

La descarga de datos todavía no está disponible.

Biografía del autor/a

Manuel José García-Mansilla, Facultad de Derecho, Universidad Austral

Abogado (Universidad del Salvador). Master of Laws (LL.M.) en Georgetown University Law Center. Profesor de Derecho Constitucional I (Universidad Austral). Miembro de la Asociación Argentina de Derecho Constitucional, del Instituto de Política Constitucional de la Academia Nacional de Ciencias Morales y Políticas, del Instituto “Segundo V. Linares Quintana” de la Academia Nacional de Derecho y Ciencias Sociales y miembro individual de la International Association of Constitutional Law. Decano de la Facultad de Derecho de la Universidad Austral.

Citas

Althouse, A. (2010). The Historical Ordinariness of Judicial Review. The George Washington Law Review, 78(6), 1123-1128.

Axel-Lute, P. (2009). Holmes v. Walton: Case File Transcriptions and Other Materials. New Jersey Digital Legal Library, Rutgers Law School, https://njlaw.rutgers.edu/collections/hw/.

Barnett, R. E. (2016). Our Republican Constitution. Securing the Liberty and Sovereignty of We the People. Broadside Books.

Berger, R. (1969). Congress v. the Supreme Court. Harvard University Press.

Blackstone, W. (1770). Commentaries on the Laws of England. In Four Books (4a ed.). Clarendon Press.

Boudin, L. B. (1929). Precedents for the Judicial Power: Holmes v. Walton and Brattle v. Hinckley. St. John’s Law Review, 3, 173-215.

Casto, W. R. (1995). James Iredell and the American Origins of Judicial Review. Connecticut Law Review, 27(2), 329-364.

Casto, W. R. (1996). Oliver Ellsworth. Journal of Supreme Court History, 1996(2), 73-91.

Casto, W. R. (2009). There Were Great Men Before Agamemnon. Vanderbilt Law Review, 62, 371-406.

Connor, H. G. (1912). James Iredell: Lawyer, Statesman, Judge. 1751-1799. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 60(4), 225-253.

Farrand, M. (1913). The Framing of the Constitution of the United States. Yale University Press.

Farrand, M. (1937). The Records of the Federal Convention of 1787 (Tomos I y II). Yale University Press.

Fenwick, C G. (1913). The Authority of Vattel. The American Political Science Review, 7(3), 395-410.

García-Mansilla, M. J. (2020). Marbury v. Madison y los mitos acerca del control judicial de constitucionalidad. Revista Jurídica Austral, 1(1), 9-89. https://doi.org/10.26422/RJA.2020.0101.gar.

Gerber, S. D. (1998). Seriatim: The Supreme Court Before John Marshall. New York University Press.

Gerber, S. D. (2011). A Distinct Judicial Power. The Origins of an Independent Judiciary, 1606-178. Oxford University Press.

Gerber, S. D. (2018). The Supreme Court Before John Marshall. University of St. Thomas Law Journal, 14(1), 27-55.

Haines, C. G. (1914). The American Doctrine of Judicial Supremacy. The Macmillan Company.

Hall, K. L. y Hall, M. D. (Eds.). (2007). Collected Works of James Wilson (Tomo I). Liberty Fund.

Hamburger, P. A. (1989). The Constitution’s Accommodation of Social Change. Michigan Law Review, 88, 239-327.

Hamburger, P. A. (2008). Law and Judicial Duty. Harvard University Press.

Hamburger, P. A. (2010). A Tale of Two Paradigms: Judicial Review and Judicial Duty. The George Washington Law Review, 78, 1162-1177.

Hamilton, A., Madison, J. y Jay, J. (1818). The Federalist, on the New Constitution, written in the year 1788. Jacob Gideon.

Higginbotham, D. (Ed.). (1976). The Papers of James Iredell (Tomo II 1778-1783). North Carolina Division of Archives and History.

Holt, E. (1998). John Blair. “A Safe and Conscientious Judge”. En Gerber, S. D. (Ed.), Seriatim: The Supreme Court Before John Marshall (pp. 155-197). New York University Press.

Lambert, R. M. (2002). The ‘Ten Pound Act’ Cases and the Origins of Judicial Review in New Hampshire. New Hampshire Bar Journal, 43, 37-55.

Lawrie, T. A. (1995). Interpretation and Authority: Separation of Powers and the Judiciary’s Battle for Independence in New Hampshire, 1786-1818. The American Journal of Legal History, 39(3), 310-336.

Leonard, G. (2006). Iredell Reclaimed: Farewell to Snowiss’s History of Judicial Review. Chicago-Kent Law Review, 81, 867-882.

Marcus, M. y Perry, J. R. (Eds.). (1985). The Documentary History of the Supreme Court of the United States, 1789-1800 (Tomo I - Parte I - Appointments and Proceedings. Columbia University Press.

McRee, G. J. (1858). Life and Correspondence of James Iredell, one of the Associate Justices of the Supreme Court of the United States (Tomo II). D. Appleton & Company.

Moore, W. D. (1990). Written and Unwritten Constitutional Law in the Founding Period: The Early New Jersey Cases. Constitutional Commentary, 7(2), 341-360.

Perley Poore, B. (Comp.). (1877). The Federal and State Constitutions, Colonial Charters, and other Organic Laws of the United States (Tomo I). Government Printing Office.

Perley Poore, B. (Comp.). (1878). The Federal and State Constitutions, Colonial Charters, and other Organic Laws of the United States (2a ed., Tomo II). Government Priting Office.

Plumer, Jr., W. (1856). Life of William Plumer. Phillips, Sampson & Co.

Publícola. (1792). Observations on Paine’s Right of Man, in a series of letter (3a ed.). Dickson y Fairbarn.

Schwartz, B. (1963). A Commentary on the Constitution of the United States (Tomo I). The Macmillan Co.

Scott, A. (1899). Holmes v. Walton: The New Jersey Precedent. A Chapter in the History of Judicial Power and Unconstitutional Legislation. The American Historical Review, 4(3), 456-469.

Sparks, J. (1832). The Life of Gouverneur Morris with selections from his correspondence and miscellaneous papers. Detailing events in the American Revolution, the French Revolution, and in the political history of the United States (Tomo III). Gray & Bowen.

Steinfeld, R. (2021). “To Save The People From Themselves”. The Emergence of American Judicial Review and the Transformation of Constitutions. Cambridge University Press.

Thayer, J. B. (1893). The Origins and Scope of the American Doctrine of Constitutional Law. Harvard Law Review, 7(3), 129-156.

Treanor, W. M. (1994). The Case of the Prisoners and the Origins of Judicial Review. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 143(2), 491-570.

Treanor, W. M. (2005). Judicial Review before Marbury. Stanford Law Review, 58(2), 455-562.

Tucker, R. J. (1896). The Judges Tucker of the Court of Appeals of Virginia. The Virginia Law Register, 1(11), 789-812.

Tucker, St. G. (1803). Appendix to Volume First. Part First of Blackstone’s Commentaries. En Blackstone’s Commentaries: with note of reference, to the Constitution and Laws, of the Federal Government of the United States, and the Commonwealth of Virginia (Tomo I). William Young Birch & Abraham Small.

Tucker, St. G. (1999). View of the Constitution of the United State. With Selected Writings. Liberty Fund.

Van Loan, E. M. (III). (2002). Ten Pound Acts: An Introduction to Original Research on the Origins of Judicial Review. New Hampshire Bar Journal, 43(1), 34-36.

Varnum, J. M. (1787). The Case, Trevett Against Weeden: On Information and Complaint, for refusing Paper Bills in Payment for Butcher’s Meat, in Market, at Par with Specie: Tried before the Honourable Superior Court, in the County of Newport, September Term, 1786. Impreso por John Carter.

Vattel, E. de. (1760). The Law of Nations, or, Principles of the Law of Nature, Applied to the Conduct and Affairs of Nations and Sovereigns (Tomo I). Impreso por J. Newbery, J. Richardson, S. Crowder, T. Caslon, T. Longman, B. Law, J. Fuller, J. Coote y G. Kearsly.

Wells, W. V. (1865). The life and public services of Samuel Adams being a narrative of his acts and opinions, and of his agency in producing and forwarding the American Revolution with extracts from his correspondence, state papers and political essays (Tomo I). Little, Brown & Co.

Wood, G. S. (1969). The Creation of the American Republic. 1776-1787. W. W. Norton & Co.

Fuentes inéditas

Carta de Edmund Randolph a James Madison. (18 de julio de 1782). Biblioteca del Congreso de los Estados Unidos, General Correspondence, 1723-1859. https://www.loc.gov/resource/mjm.01_0642_0643/?sp=1 (última visita 10/10/2022).

Carta de Edmund Randolph a James Madison. (26 de octubre de 1782). Biblioteca del Congreso de los Estados Unidos, General Correspondence, 1723-1859. https://www.loc.gov/resource/mjm.01_0774_0776/?sp=2 (última visita 10/10/2022).

“To W.N.”, Tucker-Coleman Papers, Legal Papers, Papers of St. George Tucker, Manuscripts Department, Earl Gregg Swem Library, College of William and Mary, Williamsburg, Virginia, Caja 17, Mss. 40 T79.

Fuentes publicadas

Arguments and Judgment of the Major’s Court of the City of New York, in a cause between Elizabeth Rutgers and Joshua Waddington. (1784). Samuel Loudon.

Batchellor, A. S. (Ed.). (1891). Early States Papers of New Hampshire, Including the Constitution of 1784, Journals of the Senate and House of Representatives, and Records of the President and Council, from June, 1784 to June, 1787, (Tomo XX). John B. Clarke Public Printers.

Batchellor, A. S. (Ed.). (1892). Early States Papers of New Hampshire, Including the Journals of the Senate and House of Representatives and Records of the President and Council, from June, 1787 to June, 1790 (Tomo XXI). Ira C. Evans Public Printers.

Hening, W. W. (Ed.). (1821). The Statutes at Large; Being a Collection of All the Laws of Virginia, from the First Session of the Legislature, in the Year 1619 (Tomo IX). J. & G. Cochran.

Hening, W. W. (Ed.). (1822). The Statutes at Large; Being a Collection of All the Laws of Virginia, from the First Session of the Legislature, in the Year 1619 (Tomo X). J. & G. Cochran.

Hening, W. W. (Ed.). (1823). The Statutes at Large; Being a Collection of All the Laws of Virginia, from the First Session of the Legislature, in the Year 1619 (Tomo XI). George Cochran.

Journal of the House of Delegates of the Commonwealth of Virginia; Begun and Held in the City of Richmond, in the County of Henrico. (1828). Thomas W. White.

Letters and other writings of James Madison. (1865). (Vol. I 1769-1793). J. B. Lippincott & Co.

The Constitution of North Carolina, adopted December 17, 1776; and the amendments thereto, submitted to the people by the convention which assembled at Raleigh, June 4, 1835; together with an ordinance for carrying the same into effect. (1835). J. Gales & Son.

Wilson, P. (Comp.). (1784). Acts of the Council and General Assembly of the State of New-Jersey from the Establishment of the present Government, and Declaration of Independence, to the End of the first sitting of the eight session, on 24th day of December, 1783; with the Constitution prefixed. Isaac Collins.

Publicado
2022-12-05
Cómo citar
García-Mansilla, M. J. (2022). El rol de abogados y jueces en el surgimiento del control judicial de constitucionalidad en los Estados Unidos. Revista Jurídica Austral, 3(2), 473-530. https://doi.org/10.26422/RJA.2022.0302.man
Sección
Artículos